Our Cheeses
Crowley Cheese Wheels
Crowley wheels are our signature product. These cheeses are clothbound and waxed by hand and come in 2-1/2, 5 lb, and 23-lb wheels. Hand-cut wedges are available by special order.
Crowley Cheese Blocks
Crowley blocks are hand cut and hand waxed without the cheesecloth underneath. Blocks can be ordered in various sizes. Please call us to place your order.
Crowley Cheese Samplers
We offer Crowley’s convenient 8 oz. bars in 3-, 6-, and 9-bar samplers -- something for everyone!
Aged Varieties
Mild
Sweet and buttery. Kids' favorite. Aged 2-5 months.
Medium Sharp
Combines a distinctive creamy, smooth texture with a hint of sharpness. Winner of an American Cheese Society Blue Ribbon (2005). Aged 5-10 months.
Sharp
Full-bodied flavor -- a great way to spice up a dish. Aged about a year.
Extra Sharp
Tangy and complex. Anticipated and prized by long-time customers. Aged about a year and a half.
Extra Sharp Reserve
Crowley at its finest. Aged more than two years.
Unusually Sharp
Crowley at its sharpest. Aged more than three years.
Jersey Girls Extra Sharp
More like a traditional cheddar with notes of sweet butter.
Jersey Girls Reserve
A nutty, complex, award-winning cheese aged more than two years.
Jersey Girls A2
The high butter fat of the Jersey cows’ more digestible milk gives the cheese an intense buttery flavor.
Flavors
Garlic
A long-time Crowley favorite. Not as garlicky as our Garlic Chive or our Muffaletta.
Fresh Chive
A truly elegant classic: the buttery, nutty flavor of the cheese is accentuated by fresh garden chives.
Muffaletta
A unique cheese made using Manzanilla olives, garlic, and pimento, similar to the famous New Orleans recipe, blended into our creamy cheese.
Sage
A classic, much sought-after cheese made from the same recipe used by the Crowleys over 100 years ago. Our favorite cheese in omelettes.
Hot Pepper
A blend of crushed red pepper and cayenne, with more heat than the typical "pepper" cheese.
Smoked
Naturally maple smoked, but not over-smoked!
Sophisticated-yet-rustic flavor.
Not your average smoked cheese!
Smoked Garlic
Smoky complexity.
Garlic Chive
A great marriage of two favorite flavors, with a little bite.